Last week I had the wonderful opportunity to be the judge of a high school debate competition. Not surprisingly one of the debate topics centered around “the current refugee crisis.” Unfortunately I only got to listen to one such debate. Those arguing in favor of accepting refugees did an okay job at listing out several economists, historians and anthropologists who all argue that accepting refugees will most likely improve a country’s living standards over a long term period of time (up to 1oo years!).
Those arguing against it did a fascinating job of listing out everything that is happening today. They had current and relevant data on the spread of disease, the increase of poverty among nationals and the outbreak of violence. It was all quite disconcerting and overwhelming, especially when that team pointed out, “All our opponent’s data is about what might possibly happen. Ours is about what is happening.”
They won the debate. The reality is that when people cross borders, particularly because of persecution or poverty, they bring a lot of bad stuff with them, not intentionally but it happens. This team’s crude listing of current statistics did a lot to undo the pie in the sky optimism of those who claim, “yeah but none of that will happen because, you know, love.” Sadly that seems to be the argument many are making even today. However, the threats are very real and we would be foolish to deny that.
Yet I remain in absolute favor of open borders worldwide, starting with our own. I do so not because of a pie in the sky optimism but because I am a biblical Christian. I am not a fundamentalist one but I still believe the narrative of Scripture should be given absolute primacy in all affairs.
The narrative of Scripture leaves little room for gray when it comes to feeding, clothing and accepting foreigners, even dangerous ones. God does it and God wants us to do it.
You can look at the prologue to the 10 Commandments where God says, “I am the Lord your God who brought you out of Egypt.” This statement, upon which the 10 commandments rest, calls to mind the recent past where the Israelites were strangers in a foreign land. God not only rescued them but accepted them into God’s presence. We serve a hospitable God.
You can also look at the entire book of Deuteronomy, most notably passage like chapter 10:18-19 where, “God defends the cause of the fatherless and the widow, and loves the foreigner residing among you, giving them food and clothing. And you are to love those who are foreigners, for you yourselves were foreigners in Egypt.”
Then there is chapter 16 where Moses takes great pains to clarify that the benefits of the national festivals extend to the foreigners who reside in their towns. Then the book ends with Moses pronouncing a curse upon anyone who refuses to grant foreigners justice (see 27:19).
You can also study the minor prophets who pronounce God’s wrath upon Israel over and over again because they did not accept strangers and foreigners (most notably Zephaniah 7:10).
The Psalms too proclaim that our God loves the foreigners and defends their cause. (See Psalm 94:6 and 146:9)
I wish I had the time to cite another 100 examples but clearly the Old Testament God loves immigrants, rescues immigrants, feeds and clothes them and insists we do the same.
But this isn’t just about Israel and God. Jesus is the ultimate example of a God who deserted the heavens to welcome wayward sinners into the hospitable presence of God. Jesus is the ultimate example of a God reaching out to make room in his house for us. At the same time, Jesus is the ultimate example of one who was crucified for being so hospitable. And Jesus calls us to take up our crosses and follow him.
Therefore, although I am very much inclined to accept the prognostication of the anthropologists, historians and economists who argue in the long term it will be to our benefit, I still know that in the short term we might get crucified and not just with violence but also with disease. The danger of hospitality to refugees is very real. What happened in Paris on Friday was very real. The threats of disease and violence and increased poverty (at least in the short term) are big problems. But if we trust and follow the God of Scripture, these are problems to solve, not problems which should cause us to reject God’s commands.
In close, I remember the early church. You probably didn’t know that the number one cause of death among early Christians was not martyrdom but disease. The Roman government had a way of isolating the sick and letting them die in extreme poverty. This was all so that the healthy didn’t get sick and it worked! It turns out that the healthy do stay healthy when they don’t go around sick people. The early Christians didn’t care.
They were so overwhelmed by the picture of a healthy God embracing a sick creation (and getting crucified for it) that they went to the sick, fed them, clothed them, took care of their needs and then all died of the same diseases. They did this not only willingly but joyously because they believed in The Great Physician who would one day heal them, even from death.
If we aren’t willing to become a bit poorer, a bit sicker, a bit less safe for the benefit of others, even our enemies, I just don’t think we really understand the grace and compassion of a healthy and loving God who was crucified to welcome the very dangerous, very sick and very poor sinners into a holy nation.
At least that’s my two cents.